Thanks @tkrieck, looks nice!
What happens in option 1 when selecting a template?
Does the user get a startup content?
Is the user able to switch to another template if they realize it’s not what they expected?
I’m asking because it seems to be the main difference between the two options.
Furthermore, it’s not so clear to me how the page location choice is done in option 1.
I don’t see older discussions and proposals being mentioned.
Can you check how they overlap each other?
I also think this proposal is missing an analysis of how the design choices are applicable to XWiki.