Hello!
Lately we’ve received the report of an accessibility audit of XWiki made by Dataport. I reported all the points they noted and one of those is XWIKI-21375: Videos on the help page don’t have alternatives. The page mentionned is similar to this one from dev.xwiki.org.
We decided for 15.5 that we’d remove the Youtube embed from the homepage for XWIKI-21028: Remove the video on the XS home page (forum topic).
However in this case, the videos hold an important role in the content of the page and it’s not possible to remove it without any other change.
In order to solve the aforementionned issue, I propose to
(1) Add a collapsible transcript section for each video.
I think there’s a couple other solutions that could do, here’s them and why I thought they were worse than (1) :
(2) Remove the help/video page
I think we should avoid this as this would worsen the experience for a new user. Those videos contain a lot of info, and unless we make sure all this info is in another place in the help section, this page cannot be completely deleted.
(3) Embed videos as attachments and add transcripts to them.
This was used in the help/application page, but for shorter and lower quality videos. I don’t think including video files in the build is a good practice and it might create problems down the line.
What do you think of this idea?
I know there were some issues with youtube embeds about user privacy, but I’m not sure this is quite as critical on this page.
Thanks,
Lucas.